Backes & Backes (609) 730-3838

Probate Litigation

Joint Account Challenges: You Can Win the Case and Still Pay Your Own Lawyer

A parent’s largest assets often pass outside the Will. A bank account held jointly with one child belongs to that child at the parent’s death under the Multiple-Party Deposit Account Act, N.J.S.A. 17:16I-5, unless there is clear and convincing evidence that the parent intended otherwise, and a brokerage account registered in transfer-on-death form goes to the named beneficiary. A Will that divides the estate among the children does not reach either one. The other children’s remedy is a lawsuit to set the designation aside, usually on an undue influence claim, and a 2025 Appellate Division decision shows what winning that lawsuit can cost.

Matter of Estate of Snyder, No. A-1836-23 (App. Div. July 11, 2025), is an unpublished opinion, which under Rule 1:36-3 is not precedent and binds no court, and I describe it as an illustration of settled rules. Jane Snyder died in May 2020, survived by three children. Carol lived nearby and held her mother’s power of attorney. Spencer and Linda lived in California. Jane’s 2018 Will left Carol half of the estate. In April 2019, Jane signed forms naming Carol the sole transfer-on-death beneficiary of two Charles Schwab accounts holding about $862,000, and two months later she made Carol joint owner of a PNC account that held almost $30,000 at her death. When Carol, as executor, sent her siblings an informal accounting, the residuary estate came to about $27,000, of which Spencer was to receive $10,785 and Linda less than $3,000.

Spencer and Linda sued, and they won. The trial court found that the changes had been procured by Carol, and the Appellate Division affirmed. There was no dispute that Carol stood in a confidential relationship with her mother. Jane was in chemotherapy when the forms were signed, and the medical evidence supported the claim that she was susceptible. The changes departed sharply from the plan in her Will. Carol testified that she drove her mother to the Schwab branch without knowing why they were going or what the accounts held, and the trial judge did not believe her. In a lifetime transfer, a confidential relationship is enough to shift the burden to the recipient, who must then show by clear and convincing evidence that the transfer was the donor’s free and informed act. Pascale v. Pascale, 113 N.J. 20 (1988).

They then asked that their counsel fees, which came to $235,000, be paid from the estate, and both courts said no. New Jersey follows the American rule that each side pays its own lawyer, subject to the exceptions listed in Rule 4:42-9(a). The exception for probate actions, subsection (a)(3), allows fees from the estate in a contest over the validity of a Will or codicil. Spencer and Linda had not contested the Will. They had attacked lifetime account designations, and the court declined to stretch the rule to cover them, citing an earlier Chancery Division decision, In re Estate of Balgar. The fund in court exception, subsection (a)(2), requires that the litigation have benefited someone beyond the litigants, and here the only people who gained were the three siblings who were parties.

Anyone weighing a case like this should run the arithmetic first. A judgment setting aside the designations returns the money to the estate, where it passes under the Will, and under Jane’s Will half of whatever came back belonged to Carol. Spencer and Linda’s fees came out of the other half. A challenger should measure the likely recovery against the Will’s shares and the full cost of trial, and should take that measure again at mediation.

A parent who wants one child to have more is free to do that. The durable way is to say so in a Will prepared with independent counsel, because a change made on a bank form, with the favored child driving, invites the lawsuit and leaves that child carrying a heavy burden of proof.

The Office
12 West Delaware Avenue
Pennington, New Jersey 08534
(609) 730-3838