“Convenience Accounts” in New Jersey: What Happens to a Joint Bank Account When the Owner Dies
It is common for an aging parent to add a child to a bank account so the child can pay bills and handle day-to-day finances. This seemingly sensible arrangement often creates a problem that nobody considered. When the parent dies, does the money in that account belong to the child who was named on it, or does it belong to the estate and pass under the Will? In my practice, I’ve found that everyone assumes they know the answer, but the assumptions often don’t line up.
New Jersey’s Multiple-Party Deposit Account Act governs joint bank accounts, and at death it favors the survivor. Under N.J.S.A. 17:16I-5, money left in a joint account belongs to the surviving owner “as against the estate of the decedent unless there is clear and convincing evidence of a different intention at the time the account is created,” and a survivorship right that arises under the statute cannot be changed by Will. The courts treat this as a rebuttable presumption, In re Estate of DeFrank, 433 N.J. Super. 258 (App. Div. 2013), and the evidence needed to overcome it must leave the judge with a “firm belief or conviction.” Estate of Ostlund v. Ostlund, 391 N.J. Super. 390 (App. Div. 2007).
While both owners are alive, the same statute gives the account to each of them in proportion to what each put in, N.J.S.A. 17:16I-4, so a parent who deposited all of the money owned all of it until her death, and the child’s name on the account gave the child nothing of her own in the meantime. In re Estate of Penna, 322 N.J. Super. 417 (App. Div. 1999).
New Jersey courts have long recognized that many joint accounts are opened only so that someone else can pay the depositor’s bills, and money in a true convenience account does not pass to the helper at death. The leading case is Sadofski v. Williams, 60 N.J. 385 (1972), in which Katherine Baron kept all of her money, about $45,000, in accounts held jointly with her oldest daughter. The trial court found that she meant them as convenience accounts, so that the daughter could withdraw money for her mother’s needs, and that she never intended the daughter to keep what was left. The Supreme Court affirmed, and the money went back into the estate for her heirs.
The estate’s proof is not confined to what happened on the day the account was opened. In DeFrank, two sisters disputed an account their mother had held jointly with one of them, and the Appellate Division held that a court may weigh all of the direct and circumstantial evidence, including how the account was used afterward. The mother had used the account for her own expenses and for equal gifts to both daughters and their children, the daughter on the account had kept up that pattern after taking over her mother’s finances, and the mother’s Will treated the two daughters equally. Those facts were enough to send the case back for trial. Penna was similar. The mother had added a daughter so that the daughter could handle her New Jersey banking while the mother lived in Florida, she had treated all three of her children evenly in life and in her Will, and the court observed that a power of attorney would have been the more appropriate instrument.
Both cases also turned on a second theory that often matters more than convenience. When the child on the account stood in a confidential relationship with the parent, as a child who manages the parent’s finances or holds her power of attorney usually does, the burden shifts. The challenger needs to prove the relationship only by a preponderance of the evidence, and the child must then prove by clear and convincing evidence that the account was the parent’s own free choice and not the product of undue influence. In Penna the trial court had put that burden on the wrong party, and the Appellate Division ordered a new trial. I have written about that theory separately in Undue Influence and Joint Bank Accounts.
The survivor does not always lose. In Ostlund, a father’s estate plan divided his property equally among five children and stepchildren, and his lawyer testified that the son on the account had called it a convenience account he never expected to own. The son said the opposite in his deposition, and that conflict left the estate short of clear and convincing proof, so the account passed to the son under the statute’s presumption.
For an executor, the point is that a joint account is not automatically outside the estate, and that the time to find out is early, while the bank can still produce the records showing who funded the account and how it was used, and while the people who knew the parent’s wishes are still available. For a parent who only wants help with the bills, a power of attorney does the job without changing who inherits. A parent who does want one child to have the money is better served by leaving it to that child in the Will, where the gift is plain and the other children learn of it before there is anything to fight about.
