The Life Estate Nobody Explained
In my practice I regularly come across a deed or a Will that gives someone a life estate and says almost nothing else. Sometimes it is a deed signed years ago, when a parent put the house in the children’s names and kept the right to live there. Sometimes it is a single line in a Will saying that the house goes to a spouse or partner for as long as she lives and then to the children. The people who signed these documents usually had a clear picture in their heads. The documents rarely capture it, and when the picture is missing, the law fills it in with rules most families have never heard of.
A life estate divides ownership of property by time. The life tenant owns the property for the rest of his or her life and may live in it, or rent it out and keep the rent. The remainderman, meaning the person or people named to take the property afterward, owns what is left when the life tenant dies. Both interests exist from the day the life estate is created, so neither owner can sell the whole property without the other. The life tenant can sell or mortgage only the life interest, which few buyers or lenders want, and the remainderman cannot move in or sell the house out from under the life tenant.
A Will that lets someone live in the house “so long as she wishes to live there,” or on condition that she make it her home, may give her less than an ordinary life estate. New Jersey courts have read language like that as creating a life estate that ends when she stops living there, and some older decisions treat it as only a personal right to live in the house, with no right to rent it to anyone else. When the Will says nothing about what happens if she moves out, though, the courts have tended to find an ordinary life estate, which survives a move to assisted living and can be rented. Which of these a particular sentence creates depends on its words and on whatever the court can learn about what the person who wrote it intended, and that question sits at the center of many of the disputes I see.
That arrangement sounds tidy until the first bill arrives. A house costs money every month, and a deed or Will that says only “for life” does not say who pays.
When the document is silent, New Jersey courts apply rules that go back more than a century. The life tenant pays the ordinary annual property taxes and the interest on any existing mortgage, and is responsible for ordinary repairs. The remainderman pays down the principal of the mortgage. The life tenant’s obligation for taxes and interest is generally limited to the income the property produces, or to its rental value when the life tenant lives there. The life tenant also may not let the property deteriorate or fall into tax arrears, and the law gives the remainderman remedies if the taxes go unpaid.
Insurance is where I would send anyone living under a life estate today, because neither owner is required to insure the house for the benefit of the other. A homeowner’s policy in the life tenant’s name alone generally protects only her, and if the house burns, the proceeds may be hers with no obligation to rebuild for the people who will inherit it. A policy that names the life tenant and the remaindermen together avoids the problem, and arranging one usually takes a phone call to the agent.
When a mortgaged house passes under a Will, it passes with its mortgage. Under N.J.S.A. 3B:25-1, the estate’s other assets are not used to pay the mortgage off unless the Will says so, and the familiar clause directing the executor to pay “all my just debts” is not enough. Families are often surprised by that, because the clause sounds as though it covers everything.
A life estate left to a partner who is not a spouse, civil union partner, or registered domestic partner also carries New Jersey inheritance tax, at 15 percent on the first $700,000 and 16 percent above that. The tax is measured by the value of the life interest, which is computed from actuarial tables according to the partner’s age, and it is due eight months after the death. Unless the Will directs the estate to pay it, the tax falls on the partner, who now owns an interest in a house she cannot sell and may have no other money to pay it with.
These default rules are sensible in the abstract but they rarely match what anyone intended. The person living in the house may have no idea that she owes the taxes and the interest. The children who will inherit may have no idea that they owe the principal on a house they cannot use, possibly for decades. The occupant may be unable to afford the house at all, which leaves both sides paying to preserve an arrangement neither of them wanted. Questions the document never addressed, like whether a move to assisted living changes anything or how the money should be divided if everyone agrees to sell, then turn into disputes. I have seen a single sentence in a Will produce a contested court proceeding over exactly these points.
A lifetime deed that reserves a life estate is often signed to keep a house out of probate or with an eye toward long-term care, and it can have real advantages, including favorable income tax treatment for the children when they eventually sell. It is also hard to undo. Once the deed is recorded, the parent cannot sell or refinance without the children’s cooperation, and each child’s share of the remainder is exposed to that child’s creditors from the day the deed is signed. A judgment against a son, or his bankruptcy, can reach his interest in his mother’s house, and if a child dies first, that interest passes under the child’s own Will, possibly to a spouse the parent never meant to benefit. For Medicaid purposes the deed is a gift of the remainder, and a gift made within five years before an application can delay eligibility. New Jersey’s current regulations generally do not pursue estate recovery against a life estate that ends at the owner’s death, but the recovery statute itself is written more broadly, and no one should sign such a deed on the assumption that it solves a care problem without advice about his or her actual situation.
A life estate can be exactly the right tool. Good planning starts by deciding the questions the default rules answer by accident.
