Backes & Backes (609) 730-3838

Estate Planning

Divorce Doesn’t Automatically Change Every Beneficiary Designation

Most people who have been through a divorce assume that the judgment took their former spouse off of everything. In New Jersey that assumption is mostly sound. Under N.J.S.A. 3B:3-14, a divorce revokes any revocable gift or appointment to a former spouse in a “governing instrument,” a term that reaches well beyond Wills to life insurance policies and to accounts or securities registered in pay-on-death form. After divorce, the instrument is then as though the former spouse had disclaimed.

In January 2025 the Supreme Court of New Jersey decided a case that shows where the statute stops. In Matter of Estate of Jones, 259 N.J. 584 (2025), Michael Jones bought Series EE savings bonds through his employer during his marriage and registered them payable on death to his wife, Jeanine. The couple signed a divorce settlement agreement in October 2017, and the judgment of divorce followed in January 2018. The agreement required Michael to pay Jeanine $200,000 in installments running through 2020. It said nothing about the bonds. It did contain a catch-all clause providing that any marital asset not listed belonged to whichever party had possession of it. Michael died without a Will in November 2019, with a balance still owing. Jeanine redeemed the bonds for about $77,800 and then asked the estate for the unpaid balance of the $200,000.

The estate took the position that the divorce had revoked Jeanine’s designation, and that the bond proceeds should at the least be credited against what the estate owed her. The trial court agreed with the credit. The Appellate Division reversed, 477 N.J. Super. 203 (App. Div. 2023), reasoning that federal law preempted the New Jersey statute. A unanimous Supreme Court affirmed the result by a shorter road. N.J.S.A. 3B:3-14 begins with the words “[e]xcept as provided by the express terms of a governing instrument.” A savings bond registered in pay-on-death form is a governing instrument, and its terms are supplied by the Treasury regulations, which make the surviving beneficiary the sole owner at the registered owner’s death and recognize a change of ownership by divorce only when the decree says so and the bond is reissued. Because the statute defers to those terms, there was no conflict and nothing to preempt. The settlement agreement did not change the analysis. It was silent on the bonds, and the catch-all clause settled who owned unlisted assets while both parties were alive, not who would take at Michael’s death. Jeanine kept the bonds and remained entitled to the rest of her $200,000.

Savings bonds are a small corner of most estates, but the reasoning applies wherever federal law or a plan document fixes the terms of the asset. The employer retirement plan is the largest example, because in Egelhoff v. Egelhoff, 532 U.S. 141 (2001), the United States Supreme Court held that ERISA preempts state statutes that revoke a former spouse’s beneficiary designation. A 401(k) or a group life insurance plan governed by ERISA will pay the person named on the form. The same is true of federal employees’ group life insurance under Hillman v. Maretta, 569 U.S. 483 (2013). Timing is a second limit. The statute is triggered by a divorce or annulment, and a 2026 unpublished Appellate Division decision, Matter of Estate of Burke, No. A-1493-25 (App. Div. June 29, 2026), read it not to reach a divorce that was still pending when the spouse died.

The practical points run in two directions. After divorce, critically, the forms themselves should be changed with each plan administrator and custodian, and the Will should be redone at the same time. For an executor or a family member looking at an old designation after a death, the first step is to read the instrument and the law that governs it before assuming the asset comes back to the estate. The statute often does the work, and Jones shows the cases in which it will not.

The Office
12 West Delaware Avenue
Pennington, New Jersey 08534
(609) 730-3838